I’m about to open up a can of worms in the Christian Evangelical subculture. Please don’t get too judgemental on me.
I received a very humble and respectful email asking me about my rational for reading Harry Potter. This individual saw it in a blog post somewhere. Some of you who are reading this are outside Evangelical Christianity, and you may not know that this is even an issue. But Christians everywhere think Harry Potter is of the devil, that it is introducing witchcraft to children. I tried to email the person who asked me about this, but their server is bouncing my emails back at me. So, I thought I would post the emails here, hoping that this person will come back and read my response on my blog.
Here is the question that I received:
“I have an honestly sincere question for you. Upfront I want you to know that I am asking out of a genuine desire to understand. My husband and I saw you on It’s A New Day and agreed with you and respected what you had to say(and appreciated the heart you showed). You backed it all up with scripture too,not just experience.
Can you please help me understand where you are coming from with the whole Harry Potter thing(read something on your blog)?Harry Potter uses witchcraft( right?…that is my understanding ) so what makes it ‘good’ in your eyes ?
I sincerely don’t get it but want to understand.”
So, here is what I tried to email to her:
Thanks so much for writing. I appreciate the honesty and humility with which you’ve asked the question. For a long time I just accepted the fear propaganda that is constantly being issued by the church. I too thought Harry Potter was evil, but had never read it for myself to really know. I just took the word of other Christian leaders. I was actually very surprised when I finally looked into it. To me, it is just a story. It is fantasy. It is fiction. I appreciate it as literature. The magic is over the top, not real spells as practised by witches in our day. My family reads it as fiction, with no interest in dabbling into witchcraft. It is a story, and we see it in the same light as “Lord of the Rings” or “Chronicles of Narnia.” I know others may disagree, but this is where we are at, with a clear conscience. I don’t believe that there is a conspiracy behind it, just an genuine writer using her imagination to tell a story. The story has the same elements that most stories do, the idea of good verses evil, and that there is this special hero of whom it has been foretold that he will defeat the evil protagonist. The writing itself is very good, and the story is entertaining.
I hope this helps you understand where I’m coming from.



